Personal Injury  ›  Medical Malpractice

Indiana Medical Review Panel: What Happens After You File a Birth Injury Claim

By Jill Bracken-Emerson  |  March 2026  |  12 min read

Jill Bracken-Emerson and JR Emerson - birth injury and medical malpractice attorneys serving Hamilton County, Indiana

If your child suffered a birth injury and you believe a medical provider’s negligence played a role, one of the first things an Indiana attorney will tell you is this: before you can file a lawsuit, you must first go through the Indiana Medical Review Panel. This is not optional. It is a mandatory step under Indiana law – one that has significant strategic implications for your case and that can take a year or more to complete.

For families who are already exhausted from caring for an injured newborn and navigating the healthcare system, this process can feel like another obstacle. But it serves an important function: an independent panel of physicians reviews the medical evidence and issues a written opinion on whether the care your child received met the applicable standard. That opinion – while not binding on a court – becomes powerful evidence in any subsequent lawsuit.

This article explains how Indiana’s medical review panel process works, what to expect at each stage, how long the process typically takes, and how the panel’s opinion affects your birth injury case. At Emerson Divorce and Accident Injury Attorneys, L.L.C., we guide Hamilton County families through every phase of this process – from the initial filing through trial if necessary.

Indiana Law: IC 34-18-8-4

Under the Indiana Medical Malpractice Act (IC 34-18), any claim of medical malpractice against a qualified provider must be submitted to a medical review panel before a lawsuit may be filed in court. This requirement applies to birth injury claims in the same way it applies to all other medical malpractice claims in Indiana.

What Is the Indiana Medical Review Panel?

The Indiana Medical Review Panel is a pre-litigation review process created by the Indiana Medical Malpractice Act. Its purpose is to have qualified medical professionals evaluate a malpractice claim before it proceeds to court. The panel does not award damages, issue verdicts, or make binding legal rulings. What it does is review the medical records and written submissions from both sides and issue a written opinion on one central question: did the defendant provider or providers meet the appropriate standard of care?

The panel consists of three physicians selected through a process managed through the Indiana Department of Insurance (IDOI), plus a non-voting attorney chairperson who manages the procedural aspects of the process. The physician panelists are supposed to have relevant experience – meaning that in a birth injury case involving obstetric negligence, the panel should ideally include obstetricians or other professionals familiar with labor and delivery care.

Indiana courts have consistently held that the medical review panel process is constitutional, and it remains a bedrock feature of the state’s medical malpractice landscape. Families considering a birth injury claim in Carmel, Fishers, Noblesville, or anywhere else in Hamilton County must navigate this process before bringing a lawsuit.

Step-by-Step: The Medical Review Panel Process

While every case has its own nuances, the medical review panel process follows a predictable sequence of phases. Here is how it typically unfolds from the initial filing through the issuance of the panel’s opinion.

Phase 1

Filing the Proposed Complaint

Your attorney files a “proposed complaint” with the IDOI – not the court. This document identifies the defendant providers, describes the alleged malpractice, and asserts that harm resulted. Filing this complaint tolls (pauses) the statute of limitations, protecting your legal rights while the panel process proceeds.

Phase 2

Panel Selection

Each party selects one physician panelist; those two physicians then select a third. This process requires negotiation and strategy. The defense typically selects a physician favorable to providers; your attorney selects someone whose background supports a plaintiff-favorable perspective. The non-voting attorney chair is appointed separately.

The Medical Review Panel is the first test of a case’s credibility. We review potential physician panelists carefully so the panel stays focused on the medical evidence.

Phase 3

Submission of Evidence

Both sides submit written evidence packages to the panel. These typically include medical records, nursing notes, fetal monitoring strips, imaging, and professional reports. There is no live testimony before the panel – everything is presented in writing. Your attorney’s submission is your opportunity to tell your child’s story through the medical evidence.

Phase 4

Panel Review & Opinion

The three physician panelists review the submitted materials and issue a written opinion. Each panelist may vote independently. The opinion states whether the evidence supports or does not support a finding that the defendant failed to meet the standard of care, and whether that failure was or was not a factor in the claimant’s damages.

How Long Does the Medical Review Panel Take?

This is one of the most common questions we hear from families who come to us with birth injury claims. The honest answer: it takes time – often significantly longer than families expect.

File at IDOI Evidence submitted Court / settle Panel formed Opinion issued Panel process: 12–24 months total

Typical timeline from filing to opinion:

Months 1–3

Filing & service on defendants

Months 3–8

Panel selection & formation

Months 8–16

Evidence submission & review

12–24 months

Opinion issued

Timeline varies by complexity, number of defendants, and panel formation delays. Complex birth injury cases involving multiple providers may take toward the longer end of this range.

Several factors can extend the timeline. Cases involving multiple defendant providers – for example, both the delivering obstetrician and the hospital’s nursing staff – require separate panel proceedings or coordinated multi-defendant proceedings, which adds complexity. Panel formation itself can stall when panelists are difficult to agree upon or when selected panelists withdraw. And the submission and review phase depends on when all parties complete their evidentiary packages.

One important note for families in Indiana: under IC 34-18-7-1, the statute of limitations for a medical malpractice claim is two years from the date of the alleged malpractice. For a child who was younger than six when it happened, IC 34-18-7-1(b) extends the deadline only to the child’s eighth birthday; the general rule that pauses a minor’s deadline until age 18 does not apply to malpractice claims. Filing the proposed complaint tolls the limitations period through 90 days after the family receives the panel’s opinion (IC 34-18-7-3), which is why filing before the deadline protects your rights even though the panel may take another year or two to conclude.

What the Panel’s Opinion Actually Says

The panel issues one of three possible written opinions regarding each defendant provider:

1

The evidence supports the conclusion that the defendant failed to act within the appropriate standard of care, and that the failure was a factor in the claimant’s damages.

This is the most favorable outcome for the claimant. A unanimous 3–0 opinion is extremely powerful and significantly improves leverage in settlement negotiations and at trial.

2

The evidence does not support the conclusion that the defendant failed to act within the appropriate standard of care.

This opinion does not end the case – it can be overcome at trial. However, it means the defense will enter any subsequent lawsuit with a favorable panel opinion in hand, which your attorney must be prepared to address through trial strategy and professional testimony.

3

There is a material issue of fact, not requiring professional opinion, about whether the defendant complied with the applicable standard of care.

This outcome – sometimes called the “fact question” opinion – leaves the standard of care determination to the jury without the panel’s guidance. It can be a favorable development for claimants in some situations, allowing the case to proceed without a negative physician opinion on record.

It is important to understand that panelists may vote differently – a 2–1 opinion in favor of the claimant is still usable at trial, though less powerful than a unanimous finding. The panel’s opinion is admissible at trial as evidence, and each individual panelist may be called to testify about their opinion and reasoning. This means the quality of the written submissions your attorney makes to the panel matters enormously – not only for the opinion itself but for the record that will be built for trial.

Has Your Child Been Harmed During Labor or Delivery?

The medical review panel process is complex and time-sensitive. Our birth injury attorneys have guided Hamilton County families through this process – and through the courtroom when necessary. Free case review, no fee unless we win.

What Happens After the Panel Issues Its Opinion?

Once the medical review panel issues its opinion, the case enters a new phase. Your attorney will evaluate the opinion and advise you on your options, which typically fall into three categories:

Settlement Negotiations

A favorable panel opinion – particularly a unanimous finding that the provider breached the standard of care – is a powerful settlement tool. Defendants and their insurers are acutely aware of what a panel opinion means at trial, and many cases that produced favorable opinions do resolve at this stage. Settlement in Indiana birth injury cases is subject to the damage caps under IC 34-18-8-4: total recovery is capped at $1.8 million per occurrence, with the qualified provider responsible for the first $500,000 and the Indiana Patient’s Compensation Fund covering amounts above that threshold.

Filing the Lawsuit in Court

If settlement is not reached after the panel opinion, the battle shifts to the Indiana courts. For Hamilton County families, that means the Hamilton County Superior Courts in Noblesville, located at the Hamilton County Judicial Center at 1 Hamilton County Square. For families in Zionsville or Whitestown – communities served by our Zionsville office – cases may proceed in the Boone County Circuit Court instead, depending on where the alleged malpractice occurred. The panel’s opinion becomes part of the trial record, and individual panelists may be called as witnesses.

Our team’s familiarity with local court procedures and Central Indiana juries – in both Hamilton and Boone County courtrooms – means we prepare for this transition from the very first day of the panel process. A case that looks like it will settle can quickly become a trial, and we never approach the panel phase without a full litigation strategy already in development.

Proceeding Despite an Unfavorable Opinion

A panel opinion that does not support the claimant is not the end of the road. The opinion is evidence – it is not a verdict. Indiana courts have consistently allowed plaintiffs to proceed to trial despite adverse panel opinions, so long as they have credible professional testimony supporting their claim. An experienced medical malpractice attorney in Carmel will have a strategy for addressing an unfavorable opinion long before the case gets to a jury.

How a Birth Injury Attorney Builds Your Panel Submission

Because everything submitted to the panel is in writing – and because that same written record may be used at trial – the quality of your attorney’s panel submission is not a procedural formality. It is one of the most important documents in your case. Here is what goes into a strong claimant’s submission in a birth injury panel proceeding:

Complete medical records

Prenatal records, labor and delivery records, fetal monitoring strips, nursing notes, operative records, NICU records, and any subsequent pediatric or neurological evaluations. In birth injury cases involving HIE or other brain injuries, the fetal monitoring record is often the most critical document – showing whether and when fetal distress was apparent and whether the care team responded appropriately.

Professional report(s)

A written opinion from a qualified professional – typically an obstetrician, maternal-fetal medicine professional, neonatologist, or pediatric neurologist, depending on the allegations – explaining how the defendant’s conduct fell below the standard of care and how that failure caused or contributed to the child’s injuries. The professional report must be both medically rigorous and legally precise.

Narrative statement of facts

A well-organized chronological account of the events surrounding the birth, written by the attorney, tying the medical evidence to the standard of care allegations. This document is the panel’s roadmap through the evidence – and a compelling narrative framing the claimant’s position clearly and professionally.

Damages evidence

Documentation of the child’s current condition, diagnosis, and prognosis. Life care plans, developmental assessments, and early intervention records help establish the full scope of the child’s past and future needs – which is critical both for the panel’s causation analysis and for establishing damages in any subsequent lawsuit or settlement.

Why Experience With the Panel Process Matters

Jill Bracken-Emerson has taken seven medical malpractice cases to jury verdict in her career as an attorney since 1995. Jill presented on litigation strategies to the Indiana Trial Lawyers Association in March 2026. That courtroom experience shapes how she approaches the panel process – not as a procedural hurdle, but as the first chapter of a case that may ultimately be decided by a Hamilton County jury.

The physicians who sit on Indiana medical review panels are practicing professionals. They evaluate submissions the same way they would evaluate a colleague’s work product – critically and with clinical experience. A submission that is disorganized, that buries the key evidence, or that relies on a poorly reasoned professional report will not impress a physician panel. The submission needs to be clear, medically accurate, and persuasive on exactly the right issues.

At Emerson Divorce and Accident Injury Attorneys, L.L.C., we work with highly credentialed medical professionals from the very beginning of a birth injury case – not as an afterthought once the panel is convened. Our goal is to have a submission-ready professional in place before the panel is even formed so that the moment the proceeding opens, we are ready to put our best case forward.

Birth Injury Claims in Hamilton County: What Families Should Know

  • The medical review panel must be completed before any lawsuit is filed.
  • The process typically takes 12 to 24 months from filing to opinion.
  • Filing the proposed complaint with the IDOI tolls your statute of limitations.
  • For a child injured before age six, the deadline is the child’s eighth birthday (IC 34-18-7-1(b)), not age 18 or 20.
  • The panel’s opinion is admissible at trial and can significantly affect settlement leverage.
  • An unfavorable opinion does not bar you from proceeding to court.
  • Experienced legal representation is critical from the very first filing.

If you believe your child’s birth injury may have been caused by medical negligence – whether related to hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE), a delayed cesarean section, medication errors, or any other failure in care – the time to speak with an attorney is now. The sooner you begin the process, the more time your legal team has to gather the evidence, retain the right professionals, and build the strongest possible submission before the panel is convened.

Our offices in Carmel, Fishers, and Zionsville serve families throughout Hamilton County and the surrounding area. We handle birth injury and medical malpractice cases on a contingency basis – which means you pay no attorney’s fee unless we recover for you.

We Know This Process. We Know These Courts.

Jill Bracken-Emerson has tried seven medical malpractice cases to verdict in Indiana. When you call our office, you reach a real member of our team. No fee unless we win.

This article is general information about Indiana law, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Indiana statutes change, and how any provision applies depends on the specific facts of your case.

Sources: Indiana Code (Indiana General Assembly); Indiana Rules of Court and Guidelines (Indiana Judicial Branch); Indiana Department of Insurance.

About the Author: JR Emerson

JR Emerson founded Emerson Divorce and Accident Injury Attorneys, L.L.C. in 2012 and is a former judge of the Whitestown Town Court (traffic and municipal matters). Jill Bracken-Emerson leads the firm’s personal injury practice and is involved in every injury case, with JR. JR and Jill are long-time Noblesville residents practicing from the Carmel Arts and Design District.

Read JR’s full bio

Frequently Asked Questions: Indiana Medical Review Panel

Do I have to go through the medical review panel before suing my doctor for a birth injury?

Yes. Under Indiana’s Medical Malpractice Act (IC 34-18), all malpractice claims against qualified providers – including obstetricians, hospitals, and neonatal care teams – must be submitted to a medical review panel before a lawsuit may be filed in court. There is no way to bypass this requirement. The panel process is a mandatory prerequisite, not an optional step.

How long does it take to get a medical review panel opinion in Indiana?

Most cases take between 12 and 24 months from the initial filing to the issuance of the panel’s opinion. Complex birth injury cases involving multiple defendants – for example, both the delivering physician and the hospital’s nursing staff – may take toward the longer end of that range. Delays in panel formation, scheduling conflicts among panelists, and extended submission periods all contribute to a timeline that many families find frustrating but that cannot be significantly compressed.

Can I still sue if the medical review panel rules against me?

Yes. The panel’s opinion is admissible as evidence at trial, but it is not binding. If the panel issues an opinion unfavorable to your claim, you can still file a lawsuit and present your own retained professionals to counter the panel’s findings. A skilled medical malpractice attorney will have anticipated the possibility of an adverse opinion and will have a strategy in place for addressing it effectively at trial.

Who serves on the Indiana medical review panel?

The panel consists of three physician members selected by the parties – the claimant selects one, the defendant selects one, and those two physicians jointly select the third. A non-voting attorney chairperson is appointed to manage the procedural aspects of the proceeding. For birth injury cases, the panelists should ideally have relevant experience in obstetrics, neonatology, or the specific area of care at issue. Selecting the right physician for your side of the panel is an important strategic decision that your attorney will navigate carefully.

Does the medical review panel hear live testimony?

No. The medical review panel process is entirely documentary – the panelists review written submissions from both sides, which typically include medical records, professional reports, and an attorney narrative. There is no hearing, no live testimony, and no cross-examination of witnesses. This is why the quality of your attorney’s written submission is so critical. The panel’s opinion is based entirely on what is in those documents.

What is the statute of limitations for a birth injury claim in Indiana?

Under IC 34-18-7-1, the statute of limitations for a medical malpractice claim is two years from the date of the alleged malpractice. For a child who was under six at the time, IC 34-18-7-1(b) extends that only to the child’s eighth birthday; Indiana’s general tolling rule for minors does not apply to malpractice claims. Filing the proposed complaint with the IDOI tolls the deadline through 90 days after the family receives the panel’s opinion (IC 34-18-7-3). For adult claimants (such as a mother injured during childbirth), the two-year limit applies and should not be allowed to expire.

What damages can be recovered in an Indiana birth injury case?

Indiana law caps total recovery in medical malpractice cases at $1.8 million per occurrence under IC 34-18-8-4. The defendant provider is responsible for the first $500,000; amounts above that threshold are covered by the Indiana Patient’s Compensation Fund (PCF). Recoverable damages can include past and future medical expenses, therapy and rehabilitation costs, assistive devices, lost future earnings, and compensation for pain and suffering and diminished quality of life. In cases involving catastrophic birth injuries such as cerebral palsy or HIE-related brain damage, the long-term care costs alone often approach or exceed the cap.

Where is the medical review panel proceeding filed?

The proposed complaint is filed with the Indiana Department of Insurance (IDOI), which manages the administrative aspects of the panel process. The IDOI is located in Indianapolis. This is distinct from filing a lawsuit, which takes place in the Indiana courts. For Hamilton County families, if the case proceeds to litigation after the panel process, the appropriate court is typically the Hamilton County Superior Court in Noblesville.

What types of birth injuries are most commonly involved in Indiana medical malpractice claims?

Common birth injury claims in Indiana involve hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE), cerebral palsy, brachial plexus injuries (Erb’s palsy), shoulder dystocia complications, delayed cesarean sections, improper use of forceps or vacuum extractors, failure to recognize or respond to fetal distress, and medication errors during labor. Each of these injuries may give rise to a medical malpractice claim if the evidence shows the provider’s conduct fell below the applicable standard of care.

How much does it cost to hire a birth injury attorney in Indiana?

Emerson Divorce and Accident Injury Attorneys, L.L.C. handles birth injury and medical malpractice cases on a contingency fee basis – meaning you pay no attorney’s fees unless we recover for you. We also advance case expenses, including the cost of obtaining medical records and retaining retained professionals, which we recover from the settlement. Initial case reviews are free. There is no financial risk in calling us to discuss your case.

Injured in Indiana? Talk to a Real Attorney.

Injury cases are handled on a contingency fee: you pay nothing unless we recover for you. Case reviews are free. Katie or Penny will usually answer when you call. They know every active case in the office. JR or Jill often answer the phone themselves.

Our Offices

Carmel (primary office)
Carmel Arts and Design District
1 S Rangeline Rd, Suite 400, Carmel, IN 46032
(317) 969-8000
Get directions

Fishers
11650 Lantern Rd, Suite 261, Fishers, IN 46038
(317) 434-3136

Zionsville
4582 NW Plaza West Dr, Suite 7, Zionsville, IN 46077
(317) 721-5297

Your Attorneys

JR Emerson and Jill Bracken-Emerson are long-time Noblesville residents practicing from the Carmel Arts and Design District.

Jill leads the personal injury practice and has tried seven medical malpractice cases to jury verdict in Indiana. JR is a former Whitestown Town Court judge (traffic and municipal matters).

★★★★★ 4.6 on Google (109 reviews)

The information on this website is general information, not legal advice. Contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Every case is unique and results depend on specific facts and circumstances.

© 2012-2026 Emerson Divorce and Accident Injury Attorneys, L.L.C. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy