PERSONAL INJURY | WRONGFUL DEATH

Understanding Indiana’s Comparative Fault System After a Fatal Car Accident

By Jill Bracken-Emerson | March 3, 2026 | 10 min read

Emerson Divorce and Accident Injury Attorneys, L.L.C. attorneys JR Emerson and Jill Bracken-Emerson - Indiana wrongful death and comparative fault attorneys

Losing a family member in a car accident is devastating enough without the added confusion of legal terms and insurance tactics. If your loved one was killed in a crash and the other side is claiming they were partially at fault, you need to understand how Indiana comparative fault affects a wrongful death claim – because it directly determines whether your family can recover compensation and how much that recovery may be worth.

Indiana’s modified comparative fault system, codified under Indiana Code 34-51-2, applies to wrongful death cases just as it does to personal injury claims. The critical threshold is more than 50 percent: if the deceased person is found more than 50 percent at fault for the accident, the family is barred from recovering any compensation at all. Below that threshold, damages are reduced by the deceased’s percentage of fault – a distinction that can mean the difference between a substantial recovery and nothing.

In this guide, we explain exactly how Indiana comparative fault works in a fatal car accident context, what damages are available, who has standing to file, and how an experienced wrongful death attorney can protect your family’s right to fair compensation.

What Is Comparative Fault Under Indiana Law?

Comparative fault is the legal framework Indiana courts use to allocate responsibility when more than one party contributes to an accident. Rather than treating fault as all-or-nothing, Indiana’s system recognizes that multiple drivers – or even the injured person – may share some degree of blame for a collision.

Under Indiana Code 34-51-2-5, the jury assigns a percentage of fault to every party involved in the incident, including the claimant (or, in a wrongful death case, the deceased). Under Indiana Code 34-51-2-6, the claimant’s total damages are then reduced by their percentage of fault. However, if the claimant’s share of fault exceeds 50 percent of the total fault, the claim is entirely barred.

Indiana follows what is known as the “modified comparative fault” model with a greater-than-50-percent bar. This means a plaintiff whose fault is 50 percent or less can still recover, but a plaintiff whose fault is more than 50 percent recovers nothing. This places Indiana among the majority of states that use a modified approach, as opposed to pure comparative fault states where a plaintiff can recover even at 99 percent fault.

Key Takeaway: The greater-than-50-percent Bar

Under Indiana’s modified comparative fault system, a wrongful death claim is completely barred if the deceased is found more than 50 percent at fault for the accident. At 50 percent or below, the family can still recover – but the award is reduced proportionally by the deceased’s share of fault.

How Comparative Fault Applies to Indiana Wrongful Death Claims

Indiana’s Wrongful Death Act, found at Indiana Code 34-23-1, allows the personal representative of a deceased person’s estate to file a civil lawsuit when someone dies due to another person’s wrongful act or omission. The statute specifically states that the personal representative can bring the action if the deceased “might have maintained an action had he or she lived.” This language is what connects the Comparative Fault Act to wrongful death – if the deceased would have been subject to comparative fault in a personal injury case, their estate is subject to the same rules in a wrongful death case.

What this means in practice: if a car accident kills someone and the defendant’s insurance company argues the deceased driver was partially to blame, the jury will assign fault percentages to both parties. If the deceased is assigned 30 percent of the fault and total damages are $1,000,000, the family would recover $700,000. If the deceased is assigned 55 percent of the fault, the family recovers nothing.

This makes fault allocation one of the most heavily contested issues in any Indiana wrongful death case involving a fatal car accident. Insurance companies and defense attorneys routinely attempt to shift as much blame as possible onto the deceased – who, of course, is no longer alive to tell their side of the story.

The Challenge of Defending a Deceased Person’s Actions

One of the most difficult aspects of a comparative fault wrongful death case is that the person whose actions are being scrutinized cannot testify. Unlike a standard personal injury case where the plaintiff can explain their decisions and behavior leading up to the crash, a fatal accident leaves a gap in the evidence. This is exactly the vulnerability that insurance companies exploit.

Defense strategies commonly include arguing the deceased was speeding, distracted, failed to wear a seatbelt, or failed to yield the right of way – all arguments that may be difficult to rebut without thorough investigation. This is why early involvement of an experienced wrongful death attorney is so critical. Your attorney can preserve evidence from the crash scene, secure black box data from both vehicles, obtain traffic camera footage, depose witnesses, and reconstruct the accident using professional analysis.

Who Can File a Wrongful Death Claim in Indiana?

Indiana’s wrongful death filing rules are more restrictive than most states. The claim must be filed by the personal representative of the deceased person’s estate – not by a surviving spouse, parent, or child in their individual capacity. Under Indiana Code 34-23-1-1, the personal representative files the action, and any recovery benefits the surviving spouse, dependent children, or dependent next of kin.

If there is no open estate, one must be established through probate court before the wrongful death claim can proceed. In Hamilton County, this is handled through the Hamilton County Superior Court. Families should understand that delays in opening an estate can eat into the two-year statute of limitations for wrongful death claims.

For cases involving the death of a child, the rules differ. Under Indiana Code 34-23-2-1, one or both parents – or the child’s legal guardian – may file the claim directly.

What Damages Can Be Recovered in an Indiana Wrongful Death Claim?

The damages available in a wrongful death case depend on whether the deceased was a married person with dependents or an unmarried adult without dependents. Under Indiana Code 34-23-1-1, damages for a person with dependents may include:

1

Lost Earnings and Future Income

The income the deceased would have earned over the remainder of their working life, including raises, bonuses, and benefits. Economic professionals often project these figures based on the person’s career trajectory, education, and industry.

2

Medical and Hospital Expenses

Reasonable medical costs incurred before the person’s death, including emergency treatment, hospitalization, surgery, and ambulance services related to the fatal accident.

3

Funeral and Burial Expenses

Reasonable funeral, burial, or cremation costs. These amounts are recoverable and paid to the estate for reimbursement.

4

Loss of Love and Companionship

The emotional loss experienced by surviving family members, including the sorrow, mental anguish, and loss of guidance, comfort, and companionship the deceased provided. These non-economic damages are often the largest component of a wrongful death recovery.

5

Loss of Services

The value of household services, childcare, and other support the deceased provided to the family on a daily basis.

One important limitation: the Indiana Supreme Court has ruled that punitive damages are not available in wrongful death cases. This means even in cases involving drunk driving or extreme recklessness, families cannot recover punitive damages through a wrongful death claim – although a separate survival action may offer additional avenues for recovery.

Lost a Loved One in a Car Accident?

You do not have to navigate the legal system alone. We can help you understand your family’s rights – at no cost and no obligation.

How Fault Is Determined in a Fatal Car Accident Case

Fault allocation in a wrongful death case after a fatal car accident typically involves multiple sources of evidence. Unlike a fender bender with two conscious drivers, fatal crashes often require extensive investigation because one party cannot provide their account. Evidence that plays a critical role in fault determination includes:

Police Crash Reports

The investigating officer’s report typically includes a preliminary determination of fault, witness statements, road conditions, and citations issued. While not binding on a jury, the crash report carries significant weight.

Vehicle Black Box Data

Modern vehicles record speed, braking, seatbelt use, and steering inputs in the seconds before a crash. This data can confirm or disprove claims about either driver’s behavior.

Traffic and Surveillance Camera Footage

Intersection cameras, dashcams, and nearby business surveillance systems may capture the accident in real time. This footage is often the most powerful evidence in a comparative fault dispute.

Accident Reconstruction Professionals

Engineers and accident reconstruction professionals can analyze skid marks, vehicle damage patterns, and impact physics to create a detailed picture of how the accident unfolded and who bears responsibility.

Cell Phone Records

Phone records can prove whether a driver was texting, making a call, or using an app at the time of the crash – powerful evidence of distracted driving that may shift the fault allocation significantly.

Eyewitness Testimony

Witnesses who saw the crash, the moments leading up to it, or the driving behavior of either party before the collision can provide testimony that supports or contradicts other evidence.

Preserving this evidence quickly is essential. Traffic camera footage is routinely overwritten within days or weeks. Vehicle black box data can be lost if the car is towed to a salvage yard. Witnesses’ memories fade. An experienced Indiana wrongful death attorney will send spoliation letters to preserve evidence and begin the investigation immediately.

Nonparty Fault: How Insurance Companies Try to Shift Blame

One of the most aggressive defense tactics in Indiana comparative fault cases is the use of nonparty fault allocation. Under Indiana Code 34-51-2-7 and 34-51-2-8, a defendant can ask the jury to assign fault to a “nonparty” – someone who contributed to the accident but was not named as a defendant in the lawsuit.

In a fatal car accident case, this might mean blaming a road maintenance contractor for poor signage, a vehicle manufacturer for defective brakes, or even a third driver who left the scene. By spreading the blame across additional parties, the named defendant can reduce their own percentage of fault – and their financial responsibility.

More troublingly, insurance companies sometimes use nonparty fault to push the deceased’s share of responsibility above the greater-than-50-percent bar, effectively destroying the entire claim. For example, if the defendant is 40 percent at fault and the deceased is 35 percent at fault, the family recovers. But if the defense successfully attributes 15 percent to a nonparty, the deceased’s 35 percent now represents a larger share relative to the defendant’s reduced 25 percent – and the arithmetic can change the outcome of the case.

Watch Out For: Nonparty Fault Defenses

Indiana law allows defendants to attribute fault to people who are not even parties to the lawsuit. This strategy can reduce the defendant’s share of responsibility – and potentially push the deceased’s percentage above the greater-than-50-percent bar, eliminating the family’s recovery entirely. Your attorney must anticipate and counter these defenses early in the case.

The Statute of Limitations for Wrongful Death in Indiana

Under Indiana Code 34-23-1-1, a wrongful death claim must be filed within two years from the date of the deceased person’s death. This is a hard deadline. The Indiana Supreme Court has consistently held that very few exceptions apply to this filing period, making it one of the strictest in Indiana civil law.

Families who delay in consulting an attorney risk losing their right to file entirely. This is particularly important because opening an estate – a prerequisite for filing a wrongful death action – takes time. Between identifying and appointing a personal representative, initiating probate proceedings, and gathering evidence, the two-year window can pass faster than families expect.

If you are considering a wrongful death claim after a fatal accident in the Fishers or broader Hamilton County area, reaching out to an attorney early ensures your claim is preserved and your evidence is protected.

Comparative Fault in Action: A Wrongful Death Example

To illustrate how Indiana comparative fault affects a wrongful death claim, consider this scenario:

A driver is traveling through a Hamilton County intersection on a green light but is exceeding the speed limit by 10 mph. Another driver runs a red light and strikes the first vehicle at full speed. The first driver is killed. The family files a wrongful death claim.

After investigation and trial, the jury determines the red-light runner was 80 percent at fault and the deceased driver was 20 percent at fault for speeding. Total damages are assessed at $1,200,000. Under Indiana’s comparative fault system, the family’s recovery is reduced by the deceased’s 20 percent share: $1,200,000 × 80% = $960,000.

Now consider the same scenario, but the insurance company successfully argues the deceased was also distracted by a phone and failed to take evasive action. The jury assigns 55 percent fault to the deceased and 45 percent to the red-light runner. Under Indiana’s greater-than-50-percent bar, the family recovers nothing – even though the other driver ran a red light.

This example demonstrates why the fight over fault percentages is the central battleground in any Indiana comparative fault wrongful death case.

Your Family Deserves Fair Compensation

Do not let the insurance company blame your loved one without a fight. Free case review – no fee unless we win.

Why an Experienced Wrongful Death Attorney Makes a Difference

In a wrongful death case governed by comparative fault, the difference between recovering compensation and walking away with nothing can come down to a few percentage points. Insurance companies invest heavily in minimizing their exposure – hiring accident reconstruction professionals, combing through the deceased’s phone records and driving history, and building arguments designed to push fault above the greater-than-50-percent bar.

An experienced wrongful death attorney levels that playing field. At Emerson Divorce and Accident Injury Attorneys, L.L.C., Jill Bracken-Emerson has been an attorney since 1995, handling personal injury and wrongful death cases throughout Hamilton County and central Indiana. That experience matters when the other side is trying to assign blame to a person who is no longer here to defend themselves.

Your attorney’s role in a comparative fault wrongful death case includes conducting an independent accident investigation, retaining accident reconstruction and economic professionals, deposing the defendant and witnesses, countering nonparty fault defenses, and presenting the strongest possible case to the jury – or negotiating a fair settlement that reflects the true allocation of fault.

Special Rules: Wrongful Death Claims Involving Government Entities

Indiana’s Comparative Fault Act explicitly does not apply to tort claims against governmental entities or public employees. Under Indiana Code 34-51-2-2 and the Indiana Tort Claims Act (IC 34-13-3), claims against state or local government are governed by different rules – including contributory negligence, which means even one percent of fault attributed to the claimant bars recovery entirely.

If a fatal accident involved a government vehicle, a dangerous road condition maintained by a government agency, or a poorly designed intersection, different legal standards and notice requirements apply. These claims also carry shorter filing deadlines – typically a tort claim notice must be filed within 180 days. Consulting an attorney immediately is essential in these situations.

Wrongful Death vs. Survival Actions in Indiana

It is important to understand that a wrongful death claim and a survival action are two separate legal claims that can arise from the same fatal accident. A wrongful death claim compensates the surviving family for their losses – lost income, loss of companionship, and funeral expenses. A survival action, governed by Indiana Code 34-9-3-1, compensates the deceased’s estate for damages the deceased could have recovered had they survived, including pain and suffering experienced before death.

Both claims are subject to comparative fault analysis. In cases where the deceased experienced significant suffering before passing – for example, surviving for hours or days after a catastrophic crash – a survival action can add substantial value to the family’s overall recovery. An attorney experienced in Indianapolis and Hamilton County wrongful death claims will evaluate whether both avenues of recovery are available in your situation.

This article is general information about Indiana law, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Indiana statutes change, and how any provision applies depends on the specific facts of your case.

Sources: Indiana Code (Indiana General Assembly); Indiana Rules of Court and Guidelines (Indiana Judicial Branch).

About the Author: JR Emerson

JR Emerson founded Emerson Divorce and Accident Injury Attorneys, L.L.C. in 2012 and is a former judge of the Whitestown Town Court (traffic and municipal matters). Jill Bracken-Emerson leads the firm’s personal injury practice and is involved in every injury case, with JR. JR and Jill are long-time Noblesville residents practicing from the Carmel Arts and Design District.

Read JR’s full bio

Frequently Asked Questions About Indiana Comparative Fault and Wrongful Death

Can you file a wrongful death lawsuit in Indiana if the deceased was partially at fault?

Yes. Under Indiana’s modified comparative fault system (IC 34-51-2), the family can still file and recover damages as long as the deceased’s percentage of fault does not exceed 50 percent. The recovery will be reduced proportionally by the deceased’s share of fault. An experienced Indiana wrongful death lawyer can help build the strongest case for minimizing the fault assigned to the deceased.

What happens if the deceased was more than 50% at fault?

If the deceased is found more than 50 percent at fault for the accident, Indiana’s greater-than-50-percent bar applies and the wrongful death claim is completely barred. The family cannot recover any compensation. This is why fighting the fault allocation is the most important aspect of these cases.

Who determines the percentage of fault in a wrongful death case?

The jury determines the percentage of fault assigned to each party and any nonparties. In cases that settle before trial, the fault allocation is negotiated between the attorneys and insurance companies based on the available evidence. The stronger your evidence, the better your negotiating position.

How long do you have to file a wrongful death claim in Indiana?

Indiana Code 34-23-1-1 requires the personal representative of the estate to file the wrongful death claim within two years of the date of death. Very few exceptions apply, and the Indiana Supreme Court has enforced this deadline strictly. Contact a fatal car accident attorney as soon as possible to protect your family’s rights.

Who can file a wrongful death lawsuit in Indiana?

For adult decedents, only the personal representative of the deceased’s estate can file. This person is appointed through probate court. For children, one or both parents (or legal guardians) may file. Surviving spouses and children cannot file individually – they are beneficiaries of the recovery, not the named plaintiffs.

Are punitive damages available in Indiana wrongful death cases?

No. The Indiana Supreme Court has held that punitive damages are not recoverable in wrongful death actions. This means even in cases involving extreme recklessness, such as drunk driving fatalities, the family is limited to compensatory damages. However, a separate survival action may provide additional avenues for recovery.

What is nonparty fault in an Indiana wrongful death case?

Nonparty fault is a defense strategy where the defendant asks the jury to assign fault to someone who was not named in the lawsuit. Under Indiana Code 34-51-2-7, the jury must consider the fault of all persons who contributed to the death – even those not sued. Insurance companies use this tactic to reduce their client’s percentage of fault and sometimes to push the deceased’s fault above the greater-than-50-percent bar.

Does Indiana’s comparative fault rule apply differently if a government vehicle was involved?

Yes. Indiana’s Comparative Fault Act does not apply to tort claims against government entities (IC 34-51-2-2). Claims involving government vehicles or government-maintained roads are governed by the Indiana Tort Claims Act, which applies pure contributory negligence – meaning any fault attributed to the claimant bars recovery entirely.

What is the difference between a wrongful death claim and a survival action?

A wrongful death claim compensates the family for their losses (lost income, companionship, funeral costs). A survival action compensates the deceased’s estate for damages the person could have recovered if they had survived, such as pain and suffering before death. Both can be filed from the same accident, and both are subject to comparative fault analysis.

How does comparative fault affect the value of a wrongful death settlement?

The deceased’s percentage of fault directly reduces the settlement amount. If total damages are valued at $1 million and the deceased is found 25 percent at fault, the recovery is $750,000. Insurance companies use comparative fault arguments as leverage to drive down settlement offers, which is why having an experienced attorney who can build a strong liability case is critical.

Can the insurance company blame the deceased driver who cannot testify?

Yes, and this is one of the most common tactics in wrongful death cases. Insurance companies routinely argue the deceased was speeding, distracted, or otherwise negligent – knowing the deceased cannot offer their perspective. Thorough investigation, including black box data, traffic camera footage, and witness statements, is essential to counter these arguments.

Do I need to open a probate estate before filing a wrongful death claim in Indiana?

Yes, for adult decedents. Indiana law requires that the personal representative of the estate file the wrongful death claim. If no estate has been opened, one must be established through probate court. In Hamilton County, this process is handled through the Hamilton County Superior Court. Do not wait – the two-year statute of limitations runs from the date of death, not from the date the estate is opened.

Injured in Indiana? Talk to a Real Attorney.

Injury cases are handled on a contingency fee: you pay nothing unless we recover for you. Case reviews are free. Katie or Penny will usually answer when you call. They know every active case in the office. JR or Jill often answer the phone themselves.

Our Offices

Carmel (primary office)
Carmel Arts and Design District
1 S Rangeline Rd, Suite 400, Carmel, IN 46032
(317) 969-8000
Get directions

Fishers
11650 Lantern Rd, Suite 261, Fishers, IN 46038
(317) 434-3136

Zionsville
4582 NW Plaza West Dr, Suite 7, Zionsville, IN 46077
(317) 721-5297

Your Attorneys

JR Emerson and Jill Bracken-Emerson are long-time Noblesville residents practicing from the Carmel Arts and Design District.

Jill leads the personal injury practice and has tried seven medical malpractice cases to jury verdict in Indiana. JR is a former Whitestown Town Court judge (traffic and municipal matters).

★★★★★ 4.6 on Google (109 reviews)

The information on this website is general information, not legal advice. Contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Every case is unique and results depend on specific facts and circumstances.

© 2012-2026 Emerson Divorce and Accident Injury Attorneys, L.L.C. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy